Transmission Pan Leaks

A leaking transmission pan that leaves a few drops of fluid on your garage floor might not seem like a big deal initially. Yet it could be a sign of the pan gasket failing, a puncture in the transmission oil pan, or a bad O-ring that could leave you low on transmission fluid.

Sometimes, finding the cause of a transmission oil pan can drive you nuts. All it takes is one improperly torqued bolt or a slight bend in the pan gasket flange to let a small amount of fluid escape. It could even be weeks or months after the last time you pulled the pan gasket off!

What Does the Transmission Pan Do?

The transmission pan holds the bulk of the transmission fluid, just like the oil pan holds most of the engine oil. A special gasket helps seal the transmission pan to the rest of the transmission housing to ensure no transmission fluid escapes.

When you start the car and put it in gear, the transmission pump draws transmission fluid up from the pan through the transmission filter. The fluid is then sent to help pressurized components like the valve body and the shift solenoids, which help engage the clutch packs and bands responsible for changing gears.

It also helps lubricate critical moving components like the torque converter, sun gear, planetary gears, and other moving parts. The transmission fluid continues to circulate while the car is on and in gear.

When you turn the car off, the transmission fluid gradually drains down until the vast majority of it refills the transmission pan. It then sits there, safely stored in the sealed pan until the next time you want to drive the car.

5 Causes of Transmission Pan Leaks

Improper installation and degradation of the oil pan gasket are some of the top causes of a leaking transmission pan. It’s also possible for road debris to puncture or crack the transmission pan, causing a slow leak. Sometimes, the leak isn’t immediately in the pan itself but in the O-ring connecting the check/filler tube.

You will have to use a meticulous approach to find out what’s causing your transmission pan to leak and how to fix it correctly the first time.

1. A Pan Gasket Failure

A Pan Gasket Failure

The transmission pan gasket can degrade over time, causing the pan to leak at the seam with the flange. This is even more likely to be an issue if your car frequently deals with extreme temperatures in freezing cold winters and blistering hot summers.

The transmission pan gasket is replaced every time you change the transmission fluid. So, while most gaskets have a 50,000 to 75,000-mile lifespan, most never reach the end of their natural life without some other factor being afoot.

Note

Some DIY mechanics and less-reputable repair shops will sometimes improvise a pan gasket from something like high-temperature rated silicone. If you did this or suspect the shop did, it could cause the seal to fail before your regularly scheduled transmission fluid change!

Signs of a Leaking Transmission Pan Gasket

A leaking transmission pan gasket will leave drops of transmission fluid under the car that will likely be worse the longer you let it sit. Checking the transmission fluid will reveal that it’s chronically low each morning, even if you filled it properly the night before.

If you wipe the transmission pan down or give it a quick cleaning with some automotive degreaser, you might even be able to spot the slightest wet markings on the seam where the transmission pan gasket is leaking.

How to Fix a Leaking Transmission Pan Gasket

Fixing a leaking transmission pan gasket needs to be done as part of a transmission fluid change. At the end of the process, you’ll replace the leaking transmission pan gasket with a fresh one, giving you a perfect seal.

Pro Tip

The wise move is to go the full nine yards to do a complete fluid change with a new transmission filter. It takes a little longer and costs more than a simple transmission flush, which replaces all the fluid.

The change gives you a completely clean transmission fluid slate, removing contaminants. This includes any potential pieces of the old pan gasket that might have broken loose and gotten into the transmission fluid.

2. A Deformed Flange

A Deformed Flange

One of the most common causes of a leaking transmission pan is a deformed flange after a DIY transmission fluid change. The pan is seated onto the transmission housing with a series of bolts. If you accidentally over-torque one or two of these bolts, it bends and deforms the metal slightly.

This can cause a deviation in the transmission pan gasket. A major deformation will cause a leak soon after installation. However, a minor deformation might take months to reveal itself fully.

Note

I’ve seen many of these over the years, and I’ve noticed that small deformations in the flange seem to start leaking right around the first cold snap of the winter, especially in cars parked outside rather than in a heated garage.

How to Fix a Deformed Flange

The problem with a deformed flange that causes a transmission pan leak is that you can’t just crank down tighter on the bolts. A lot of DIY mechanics try to get all “Hulk Angry” cranking down all the bolts in the area, trying to bend the metal to their will.

Then they just end up with even more leaks and deformed metal than before as it turns the metal of the bolt holes into high spots.

Pro Tip

There are tons of videos and forum posts on the internet from people who have come up with creative ways to remove the pan and restore its straight angles. They all sound convincing in their own way.

Yet, even if you’re the master of level measurement and the Michelangelo of metal grinders, there’s still a chance that it will leak. You won’t know until you reinstall and refill the transmission fluid.

The wise move is to replace the transmission pan altogether. Especially when you consider the time it takes to pull off all the questionable DIY flange straightening hacks then take the time to torque the bolts to the correct degree of tightness properly.

The part cost for a new transmission oil pan for most domestic models ranges from as low as $85 to as much as $210.

The real-world average is around $165, not counting the cost of a new pan gasket, which is usually $25 or less.

3. Loose Bolts on the Transmission Pan

Loose Bolts on the Transmission Pan

A leaking transmission pan can also be due to loose or under-tightened bolts on the transmission pan flange. This is the opposite end of the spectrum from overly tightened bolts and can be easier to fix. It’s a common DIY transmission fluid change mistake.

It could also be due to the bolt hole being stripped out. This is somewhat more common in older cars that have been through a lot of DIY transmission fluid changes.

Signs of Loose Transmission Pan Bolts

Loose transmission pan bolts can do more than leak transmission fluid. How they affect the system’s pressure when the car is running can also lead to delayed shifting or when the transmission gets stuck in gear.

Depending on the severity of the leak, there might also be tiny bubbles in the transmission fluid from air getting drawn in through the leak. However, this isn’t always the case.

How to Fix a Loose Transmission Pan Bolt

If you’re lucky, fixing a leak due to a loose transmission pan bolt is as simple as torquing it to the correct degree of tightness. This is usually 7 to 9 foot-pounds; you can find the correct torque setting in your owner’s manual.

However, there are some concerns about the tightness of other bolts and the chance that you have stripped threads in that hole of the transmission housing.

If you properly torque the bolt and you still have a leak later on, or it just won’t torque to the correct setting, you’ll need to tap the bolt hole.

This is usually beyond what a DIY mechanic can handle, but if you have the tools and the skills, you should be able to do it in under an hour.

4. A Crack or Puncture in the Transmission Pan

A Crack or Puncture in the Transmission Pan

A leaking transmission pan from road debris puncturing into the pan is always an emergency. Even a small hole in the transmission pan can leak out a dangerous fluid volume quickly. This can leave the transmission under-lubricated and at risk of serious damage.

It’s best to tow a car with a damaged transmission pan home or to the nearest mechanic.

How to Fix a Damaged Transmission Pan

A leaking, damaged transmission pan and a completely new pan gasket must be replaced. The wise move is to perform a complete transmission fluid change with a new filter.

This gives you the best chance of clearing out any particulate debris that might have gotten into the fluid when a foreign object damaged the pan.

5. The Transmission Fill Tube O-Ring

The Transmission Fill Tube O-Ring

If you’re having trouble finding the transmission pan leak and are certain it’s not the gasket, it might be the O-ring on the fill tube. This is above the pan gasket but can allow transmission fluid to seep down until it catches on the lip of the pan gasket, masking the true source.

You can usually confirm this by thoroughly cleaning the transmission pan of all leaked fluid and road grime. Then wipe it dry, and have someone add a small dose of transmission fluid while you lay under the pan. Feel around the O-ring. It should start to feel wet in five minutes or so as a miniscule amount of transmission fluid starts to seep out.

How to Fix a Transmission Fill Tube O-Ring

If your transmission pan leak is due to a bad O-ring, replacing the entire fill tube is wise. Unfortunately, this sounds easier than it is, as the tube tends to snake around and run past a lot of other components.

The part cost for the new fill tube will usually be between $45 to $75. However, there are certainly some foreign models that can be crazy expensive!

Just how long it takes you to replace the tube and the O-ring yourself will vary wildly based on the model. The wise move is to plan on it taking at least two to three hours. Then you can rejoice if it only takes half an hour!

If a mechanic replaces the transmission fill tube and O-ring, the final repair bill will add another $75 to $125.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can I drive with a leaking transmission pan?

Driving with a leaking transmission pan is always a risky gamble. You know the fluid is leaking out, which is going to affect pressure-responsive components like the shift solenoids and the valve body. It also means moving parts aren’t going to be sufficiently lubricated and the transmission is at increased risk of overheating!

What’s the difference between a transmission fluid change and a flush?

Anytime you remove the transmission pan, you need to replace the transmission fluid with either a flush or a change. With a transmission fluid change, you’re leaving the old filter in place and simply dumping the old fluid as part of the pan removal process. This is fine. if there aren’t any concerns about mechanical faults or contamination in the system, and you have 30,000 miles or more until your next scheduled transmission fluid change.

Why does my transmission pan gasket leak more when the car is shut off?

When the car is running, the transmission fluid constantly circulates through the housing, the valve body, the torque converter, and other moving parts of the transmission. When you shut the car off, the fluid gradually drains down to the transmission oil pan. This allows a greater fluid volume to be constantly present along the seam with the gasket or a puncture that’s higher up in the pan.

Conclusion

A leaking transmission pan can usually be traced back to some sort of installation issue that affects the integrity of the gasket seal. Of these, DIY transmission fluid changes where the bolts aren’t torqued to the proper foot-pounds are the most common.

A transmission pan gasket leak from over-tightened bolts can vary in severity. A minor leak might not reveal itself until winter’s outside temperature gets cold. While you might be able to modify the transmission pan flange, the wise move is to buy a new replacement pan and gasket.

A loose bolt could also cause a transmission pan leak, but the real question comes down to what caused it to be loose. If it’s a stripped bolt hole, and not just forgetting to torque the bolt properly, you might have to tap the hole.

If your leaking transmission pan problem is due to a puncture or crack from running something over, the wise move is to have the car towed. The entire transmission pan will need to be replaced, and you should perform a complete transmission change, including a fresh replacement filter.

Jason Farrell

Written By

Jason Farrell

Jason Farrell is a certified master technician, the editor of Mechanic’s Diary in Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania. He is ASE (Automotive Service Excellence) certified and earned a Bachelor’s Degree in Automotive Technology from Pittsburg State University. With nearly 18 prior years of experience in the automotive field, he has extensive knowledge about Domestic, European, and other foreign makes and models of cars and light trucks. Jason’s experience working as a technician and service manager at dealerships, gave him the experience and know-how of most aspects of inspection, diagnosis, and repair from engine and drivability to electrical, HVAC, brakes, steering and suspension and everything in between.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *